This should end the Gaga talent debate

[Dasein]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NM51qOpwcIM&feature=player_embedded#

Now please stop being foolish. It's called talent. No question about it. circa 2005.

[parkhead]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NM51qOpwcIM&feature=player_embedded#

Now please stop being foolish. It's called talent. No question about it. circa 2005.

and smart enough to know how to push peoples buttons

p

[jimfog]

"Pokerface", indeed.

Most people are so shallow and caught up in their prejudices, they can't see past the obvious irony.

[Frater B]

This should end the Gaga talent debate

I doubt it!

There will always be naysayers.

__

[padavis]

I like some of her stuff. Don't really get the weird stuff but I guess thats just pop dance stuff. I wonder if she will do like a John Mayer type thing were she breaks in with this freaky stuff and then she sits down and writes and works on Nora Jones type stuff?

[dk123123dk]

Its a shame that she has to do all the dancing/over the top stuff to sell records/get attention.

If she would just do songs like this, musicians will love her, but she would be obscure and unheard of to the rest of the world.


dk

[atquinn]

Its a shame that she has to do all the dancing/over the top stuff to sell records/get attention.

Perhaps she enjoys doing all that stuff?

-Austin

[gainiac]

Its a shame that she has to do all the dancing/over the top stuff to sell records/get attention.



dk

Uhm....Maybe she likes to dance?

To the OP.......

As far as ending debates about the merits of artists.....

It will never happen here.

You have guitarists here who will never step beyond amateur simply because they don't have the ears to be a musician for whatever reason.

Then you have guitarists who happen to be musicians and, although they may not prefer or like a certain style/genre, they have put in the work, have been around the block, and know what musicianship and performance is. It's hard work, most have the humility to respect that.

[mcgriff420]

Thanks for posting :aok

I'm of the mind that she had to have quite a bit of talent to get where she is -no matter what hype and marketing is behind her.

You don't have to like the music but appreciate the talent.

Whenever I get it in my head that so and so is a 'no talent' and all hype I make it a point to seek out some live youtube or better yet catch a live show.

More often than not I get a new respect for them.. Like Robben Ford, after endless posts and discussions on here about him I made up my mind that I couldn't stand him.
But.. after I checked out some of his sideman stuff I decided that he was a really talented guitar player.

..

[ElDiabloBlanco]

"Pokerface", indeed.

Most people are so shallow and caught up in their prejudices, they can't see past the obvious irony.


On the money.
There's good and bad in all music.
She's good.

[Dickie Fredericks]

All I know is that VMA performance of Paparazzi was awesome. I actually got chills and said to myself that that was a great performance.

[soapvox speaker]

okay, i am officially a fan.

[jazzandmetal?]

Holy Crap!

That was simply fantastic. Thanks so much for posting it!

Call me crazy, but listening to that, I was reminded of Freddie Mercury's style/talent.

Jade

I thought the exact same thing.

Very talented.

[Dickie Fredericks]

The clip shows that she is a business minded individual as well as a talent.

Ya gots to do what you gots to do.

Make a killing doing that awesome tune in the clip? Probably not.

Do the MTV pop thing she is doing? Cash in.

I have no problem with that.

[furry]

hmmmmm...

[Jahn]

I loved the last comment by the judge - "Norah Jones, Look Out!"

[gainiac]

I loved the last comment by the judge - "Norah Jones, Look Out!"

I think their is plenty of room for a world with both. IMO Norah Jones has a timelessly beautiful voice and she is a fabulous songwriter and musician.

[Plague Dog]

I didn't know there was ever a debate...

[KRosser]

This is what I don't get about these "debates" - even if it could be proven beyond a reasonable doubt that Lady Gaga has no talent, whatever 'talent' is anyway, what's she supposed to do once we reach that verdict?

Quit?

Fat chance.

[Dana Olsen]

Very nice - she 'mos 'def has skills.

Thanks for posting this, Dana O.

[Steve Foley]

Holy Crap!

That was simply fantastic. Thanks so much for posting it!

Call me crazy, but listening to that, I was reminded of Freddie Mercury's style/talent.

Jade

I hadn't considered that, but that's probably an excellent analogy. Good call.... ;)

[Plague Dog]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oP8SrlbpJ5A

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=laIr_d0hFB8&feature=related

Lot's of something... most people call it talent.

[OldSchool]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NM51qOpwcIM&feature=player_embedded#

Now please stop being foolish. It's called talent. No question about it. circa 2005.

That was very nice indeed. Too bad its 2009 and she is just a shell of that once beautiful young Lady. :dunno

[re-animator]

that was pretty great. speaking as a full aesthetic though, she's doing bigger and better things now. Of course a lot of people here don't realize that music doesn't end with the notes.

[DC1]

"Pokerface", indeed.

Most people are so shallow and caught up in their prejudices, they can't see past the obvious irony.

Not that there's anything wrong with that...


:worried



dc

[mlynn02]

All I know is that VMA performance of Paparazzi was awesome. I actually got chills and said to myself that that was a great performance.

+1! VMA jam was seriously awesome.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oP8SrlbpJ5A

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=laIr_d0hFB8&feature=related

Lot's of something... most people call it talent.

love these.

[gainiac]

That was very nice indeed. Too bad its 2009 and she is just a shell of that once beautiful young Lady. :dunno

Seems like she's living her dream and all her hard work has paid off. You a mind-reader?

[jesserides2005]

Wow! Just Wow!

OP, thank's for turning me onto another great artist! :aok

[onemind]

I enjoyed that, and like the visuals in her videos.

[authen]

That was good. Thanks for posting.

[Jube2550]

Holy Crap!

That was simply fantastic. Thanks so much for posting it!

Call me crazy, but listening to that, I was reminded of Freddie Mercury's style/talent.

Jade


I did a double take to one of her videos and swear she was playing the "Death on Two Legs" intro, sold me right there. That is my favorite Queen song. I think she was influenced for sure.

At the end of the day, with the economy in the toilet, unemployment at the highest in 20+ years, dubious leadership and all the problems in the world we need more Ga Ga!! Guilty of guilty pleasure...check!

[pickaguitar]

That was good! thx

[teleman1]

Bad comparsion but she is superior to Britanny Spearers in every way, She's a class act who knows what it takes. I'll be expecting better and more and I am sure she will deliver.

[teleman1]

All we need is, Lady Ga Ga, Not all the Goo Goo. Sing it with Radio GA GA and have fun!

[whitecadillac]

I was really impressed. I think the clip showcases her talent. I think the wigs, see through outfits etc. detract from it.

IMO, YMMV etc.

[bartmcartman]

My guess is that without the wigs, see through outfits, contact lenses and over the top dancing and stage production this thread wouldn't even exist. Seems like she knows what she's doing to me! I say more skimpy outfits with talent to back it up! Who wants to see Kiss without the makeup?

[RMcFarland]

I like some of her stuff. Don't really get the weird stuff but I guess thats just pop dance stuff. I wonder if she will do like a John Mayer type thing were she breaks in with this freaky stuff and then she sits down and writes and works on Nora Jones type stuff?

Why would she want to sit down and work on "Nora Jones" type stuff? To put people to sleep? To get in touch with her boring and safe side?

[RonH]

She sounded good. Still don't like what she is doing now, but I liked what she was doing back then!

[rogwerks]

it'z a fraud...

[2HBStrat]

Thanks for posting that. I liked her already, and even more now. That reminds me a little of Laura Nyro.

[Dexter.Sinister]

Well done.

DS

[KRosser]

Thanks for posting that. I liked her already, and even more now. That reminds me a little of Laura Nyro.


Funny...it did me too...and I was gonna say that.

I couldn't quite put my finger on why, though...a tiny bit of similarity in the vocal style. Nyro definitely had more of a 'Brill Building with a touch of Broadway' vibe than this, which was more straight contemporary pop

And then I realized - it's the haircut...and then I thought -nah, best not to say anything then...

[speedtaco]

I had never heard her music until I watched that crazy new video someone posted the other day. I like that, and i like this. She may be crazy, and look weird, but she has the talent to back it up. Not like a lot of these 'product' performers we see so much today. Thanks for the post.

[re-animator]

If internet messageboards were prevalent 40 years ago i'm sure a lot of the incendiary remarks against Gaga would also have been tacked at guys like Freddy Mercury, Michael Jackson, Prince, Madonna, etc.


oops, just reread some of my comments. its 2009 and people are still hating on a lot of those artists.

[fredgarvin]

I really don't care a whit about whether someone is talented if I don't like their stuff. Even if I do I don't see the point of trying to sell it to those who don't.

[Kaji13]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XaEc_5abpfA


Debate even over-er

[OldSchool]

Seems like she's living her dream and all her hard work has paid off. You a mind-reader?


I just don't see how it compares at all to the Crap she is spewing today and her looks. If you want to judge a person by how much money they have , then great.........yeah she's successful. The public will buy anything you place in front of them. Reality shows are proof of that. But by talant and songwriting, that girl now is just a shell of what she once was. I really hope she is surrounded by good people and not indulging in the rock Star life style too much. As much as I do not care for her music , I would hate to see her end up in a rehab.

[OldSchool]

I really don't care a whit about whether someone is talented if I don't like their stuff. Even if I do I don't see the point of trying to sell it to those who don't.

Exactly. :agree
We don't get it, and I think they know alot here won't......but it lights their fire for some reason to keep trying to get us to see something we never will.

Doesn't matter if you take it out of the Toliet bowl and serve it with Lobster..........Crap is still Crap!!

[epluribus]

But why would anyone want to end The Lady Gaga debate? Then what would we talk about...gear? :eek:

[Kaji13]

I'm so confused by all of this. Seems people just need an excuse to get under one another's craws.

[ivers]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XaEc_5abpfA


Debate even over-er

Bernard Butler kills. :bow

[MichelleTele]

She has talent no doubt.

But I dont get it why she's considered a goddess in the LGBT community...

[Jon Silberman]

I really don't care a whit about whether someone is talented if I don't like their stuff.
A serious response: I actually do care about talent even when I don't like someone's stuff for several reasons, including that sometimes - just sometimes - when I'm convinced someone truly is talented, I like to revisit my
dislike to determine if perhaps the reason I'm missing out is my own small-mindedness. If so, it gives me the option to expand my horizons by opening my mind.

Even if I do I don't see the point of trying to sell it to those who don't.
Sell, no, but to be fair to the OP, he's not selling it to you. He's giving it away. There are worst traits in life than wanting to share things you like with others, especially when they're the ones who click into your thread. ;)

[drgonzoguitar]

The clip shows that she is a business minded individual as well as a talent.

Ya gots to do what you gots to do.

Make a killing doing that awesome tune in the clip? Probably not.

Do the MTV pop thing she is doing? Cash in.

I have no problem with that.

Again, Dickie speaks the truth!

[OldSchool]

The clip shows that she is a business minded individual as well as a talent.

Ya gots to do what you gots to do.

Make a killing doing that awesome tune in the clip? Probably not.

Do the MTV pop thing she is doing? Cash in.

I have no problem with that.


I gotta agree with that perspective. http://www.thegearpage.net/board/images/icons/icon14.gif

[Kaji13]

Bernard Butler kills. :bow
I know, he's a totally amazing player. Sort of Like Johnny Marr and Kevin Shields all rolled into one.

[gainiac]

I just don't see how it compares at all to the Crap she is spewing today and her looks. If you want to judge a person by how much money they have , then great.........yeah she's successful. The public will buy anything you place in front of them. Reality shows are proof of that. But by talant and songwriting, that girl now is just a shell of what she once was. I really hope she is surrounded by good people and not indulging in the rock Star life style too much. As much as I do not care for her music , I would hate to see her end up in a rehab.


Your a presumptuous ignorant fool. Nothing you've stated is based on any know facts. More straw-man crap, who said anything about money, or reality shows?

Like I asked before, are you telepathic? Do you have a crystal ball? Omniscient? What about pop, costume, and choreographed dance draws you to the conclusion that she is a drug addled RnR "shell" of a person?

Misogyny, jealousy?

If the public will buy anything why don't you make a record?

[gainiac]

Exactly. :agree
We don't get it, and I think they know alot here won't......but it lights their fire for some reason to keep trying to get us to see something we never will.

Doesn't matter if you take it out of the Toliet bowl and serve it with Lobster..........Crap is still Crap!!

You're missing the point. It's not about liking it or not. I don't care. It's certainly not in my daily rotation because stylistically it is most definitely not my thing. With that being said If you really knew what being a musician is you'd at least respect others for working hard instead of slagging it.

[brothertupelo]

does lady gaga give songwriting credit to devo on her new single? because the verse is basically "cars"

[Simto]

I think she's horrible, but that performance was great, she should have stayed in that vibe. But if she's happy then what do i care :)

[razorbladeSD]

does lady gaga give songwriting credit to devo on her new single? because the verse is basically "cars"

Why should Devo get credit?

Gary Numan did Cars.

[willyboy]

She does sing and play quite nice in that solo format. Just unfortunate that her career is being made on the pop drivel she's currently performing, the cheese-wiz of music. Blechhh! But that's just my opinion.

[Kaji13]

Your a presumptuous ignorant fool. Nothing you've stated is based on any know facts. More straw-man crap, who said anything about money, or reality shows?

Like I asked before, are you telepathic? Do you have a crystal ball? Omniscient? What about pop, costume, and choreographed dance draws you to the conclusion that she is a drug addled RnR "shell" of a person?

Misogyny, jealousy?

If the public will buy anything why don't you make a record?
Couldn't have said it better myself.

[brothertupelo]

Why should Devo get credit?

Gary Numan did Cars.
oops. didn't know that. in any case, i'm not the only one who hears it, am i?

[gainiac]

oops. didn't know that. in any case, i'm not the only one who hears it, am i?

Cars is a cool tune...what part of the song you thinking of? (You said verse....I'll listen...didn't notice at all the first time!)

[Spudman]

I guess i'm in now too. I never knew. That was really good.

[grateful.ed]

It makes women drink booze, thus,
I find utility in it.

[gregc]

A Gaga debate? What's a Gaga??????????

[the_Chris]

She really is a very impressive songwriter when she challenges herself. I dug some of the stuff on her Lady Gaga album, but lyrically some of it fell short. My wife is a big fan, I'm sure I'll hear the new album soon enough.

[Kaji13]

It makes women drink booze, thus,
I find utility in it.
:banana

[OldSchool]

=gainiac;7159694]Your a presumptuous ignorant fool. Nothing you've stated is based on any know facts. More straw-man crap, who said anything about money, or reality shows?

Please keep this on topic , non attacking and not personal.........Who said anything about reality shows? I didn't know this was a conversation between just you and me.Last time I checked I can add whatever I want to the conversation.Do I need to check with you first? :rolleyes: Seriously bro.......if you can't handle intelligent conversation, walk away.



Like I asked before, are you telepathic? Do you have a crystal ball? Omniscient? What about pop, costume, and choreographed dance draws you to the conclusion that she is a drug addled RnR "shell" of a person?
Don't remember seeing a Conclusion anywhere in my train of thought . The video shown shows a beautiful talented young woman, fame and this lifestyle has chewed up more people then perserved them. My wish was only that she remained the person in that video at some level someway.


Misogyny, jealousy? I was going to ask the same about you......but you seem really occuipied with this strawman dude lately........:rolleyes:


If the public will buy anything why don't you make a record?


Can I ask where yours is? After that can you please direct me to the Rule here at TGP that states you need to have a recording contract to comment here in the forum. I was under the impression that this was a Guitar discussion forum. :huh If I'm wrong please let me know ok?


^^^^^
Is that a strawman argument too? :rolleyes:

[OldSchool]

Couldn't have said it better myself.

Please do then. An original thought , maybe an intelligent argument might impress better then just agreeing with the masses . http://www.thegearpage.net/board/images/icons/icon12.gif

[OldSchool]

It makes women drink booze, thus,
I find utility in it.


Again.......another perspective I can totally get behind!! Some of you here do make alot of sense. http://www.thegearpage.net/board/images/icons/icon14.gifhttp://www.thegearpage.net/board/images/icons/icon12.gif

[padavis]

Why would she want to sit down and work on "Nora Jones" type stuff? To put people to sleep? To get in touch with her boring and safe side?

haha I guess I just like boring and safe more than weird and freaky... sorry I posted my opinion. I guess I am going to translate your slam as you like her as she is and you hope she keeps working in this style? Good for you.

[Jon Silberman]

Jerry Garcia famously said about his band, "The Grateful Dead are like licorice. Not everyone likes licorice but the people who do really do."

I don't interpret RM's post as a slam at all. I think it's a legit observation. There's a whole lotta projecting going on in this thread. Why not simply accept there's an entertainer out there whose career goals and musical interests differ with yours while matching up well with a huge segment of the listening/viewing/buying public?

And Nora Jones (who I like alot, BTW) can do her thing for her audience!

[Ulysses]

A serious response: I actually do care about talent even when I don't like someone's stuff for several reasons, including that sometimes - just sometimes - when I'm convinced someone truly is talented, I like to revisit my
dislike to determine if perhaps the reason I'm missing out is my own small-mindedness. If so, it gives me the option to expand my horizons by opening my mind.



Yes, kinda like this thread.... I stuck with it just long enough to find something worth reading. This also brings me back to what it was about music that I fell in love with as a kid. As my tastes become more refined I have to be careful not to assume I have nothing to learn from or be inspired by outside of what I already feel comfortable with. I think this may be how many become stagnated musically.

[Jazzydave]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NM51qOpwcIM&feature=player_embedded#

Now please stop being foolish. It's called talent. No question about it. circa 2005.

Loved the music...didn't care for that goofy "someone taught me how to smile while performing" thing she had going on. Its like those kids in drama class that over act.

Great voice, definitely a talented woman!

[Kaji13]

Please do then. An original thought , maybe an intelligent argument might impress better then just agreeing with the masses . http://www.thegearpage.net/board/images/icons/icon12.gif
There's no point in being redundant. He said everything I wanted to say but was too lazy too.

[JZWest]

i've heard her name here and there, and then checked out a few of her songs, and now the one in this thread. i think she is an enormously talented person and though I don't really care for the style music she is currently performing I really really like how she does it!

[mojocaster.com]

1. my simple personal view is that if her music was still what was displayed in that first video, I'd be a fan.
2. the stuff she produces today is of no value to me, period.

[sfarnell]

Your a presumptuous ignorant fool. Nothing you've stated is based on any know facts. More straw-man crap, who said anything about money, or reality shows?

Like I asked before, are you telepathic? Do you have a crystal ball? Omniscient? What about pop, costume, and choreographed dance draws you to the conclusion that she is a drug addled RnR "shell" of a person?

Misogyny, jealousy?

If the public will buy anything why don't you make a record?

You may as well give up with OldSchool He enters into threads just to spew ignorance and to stir things up. The other day he went into a thread about the Grateful Dead and went off on their audience calling them a bunch of homeless bums that pissed all over HIS city.

Don't waste your keystrokes on OldSchool.

[OldSchool]

There's no point in being redundant. He said everything I wanted to say but was too lazy too.


Ahhhh. Thanks for your honesty. http://www.thegearpage.net/board/images/icons/icon14.gif So he said everything you wanted to say , but you felt the need to agree with him attacking me , so you posted it again. Thats all well and good.........but on one hand all of you are preaching freedom of speech, to be free to perform and express yourself . And then all of you condemn me for expressing mine.

The comments were never attacking , and I always gave reasons and explained as to why I felt the way I did. Not to mention this is a GUITAR based Forum. So you would think you would get some people that are interested in GUITAR related music. I think your aware of that going in.

Whatever floats your boat. :bkw

[OldSchool]

1. my simple personal view is that if her music was still what was displayed in that first video, I'd be a fan.
2. the stuff she produces today is of no value to me, period.

Thank You.Apparently I'm not allowed to have that same opinion. :dunno

[ducatisteve]

Not to mention this is a GUITAR based Forum. So you would think you would get some people that are interested in GUITAR related music. I think your aware of that going in.

Really?

This is probably a waste of time, but you are in the Sound Hound Lounge, where we (musicians) have "General discussion about anything related to music."

But I think you're aware of that going in.

[OldSchool]

You may as well give up with OldSchool He enters into threads just to spew ignorance and to stir things up. The other day he went into a thread about the Grateful Dead and went off on their audience calling them a bunch of homeless bums that pissed all over HIS city.

Don't waste your keystrokes on OldSchool.

At least I tried to make amends on that thread and put it behind me. You felt the need to keep it going on. Believe me I could have kept that train going Bro......but out of respect for my man Jon Silberman who I have Mucho respect for I let it go. I suggest you do the same . You do not want me opening the can of worms that is the Deadheads . Remember John Rambo's Famous words to the Sheriff in the first Blood Flick? LET IT GO. http://www.thegearpage.net/board/images/icons/icon12.gifhttp://www.thegearpage.net/board/images/icons/icon14.gif

[OldSchool]

Really?

This is probably a waste of time, but you are in the Sound Hound Lounge, where we (musicians) have "General discussion about anything related to music."

But I think you're aware of that going in.

Absolutely!! Thats exactly what I was doing. But apparently only one opinion is allowed. You guys want to prove that your so open minded........in truth your just the opposite. http://www.thegearpage.net/board/images/icons/icon13.gif My point was that if you are on a guitar related Forum don't be so appalled when you get people that dig guitar orientated music and not electronica psycho babble .

[John Alexander]

At least I tried to make amends on that thread and put it behind me. You felt the need to keep it going on. Believe me I could have kept that train going Bro......but out of respect for my man Jon Silberman who I have Mucho respect for I let it go. I suggest you do the same . You do not want me opening the can of worms that is the Deadheads . Remember John Rambo's Famous words to the Sheriff in the first Blood Flick? LET IT GO. http://www.thegearpage.net/board/images/icons/icon12.gifhttp://www.thegearpage.net/board/images/icons/icon14.gif

...yea, but you usually play the role of the cop who was the entire cause for Rambo's rampage, he wanted to arrest Rambo for vagrancy in backwater USA (to quote Col. Troutman)...he fell out of the helicopter like a dumbass...bro...:boxer:D:p

[OldSchool]

...yea, but you usually play the role of the cop who was the entire cause for Rambo's rampage, he wanted to arrest Rambo for vagrancy in backwater USA (to quote Col. Troutman)...he fell out of the helicopter like a dumbass...bro...:boxer:D:p

How's that? How does not liking Lady ga Ga = that? :confused:


I'll tell you what......I'll keep my chin up high. I never once, not once attacking anyone personally here or in any other thread. And it wa sthe Sheriff that wanted to arrest John Rambo. His deputy fell out of the Helicopter. Very bad anology. But.........if you would like to pick this back up over at the Dead thread Just let me know. I graciously left but can drag the legacy of Jerry and his Brethern as deep down as you make me.

[John Alexander]

How's that? How does not liking Lady ga Ga = that? :confused:


I'll tell you what......I'll keep my chin up high. I never once, not once attacking anyone personally here or in any other thread. And it wa sthe Sheriff that wanted to arrest John Rambo. His deputy fell out of the Helicopter. Very bad anology. But.........if you would like to pick this back up over at the Dead thread Just let me know. I graciously left but can drag the legacy of Jerry and his Brethern as deep down as you make me.

...I confused the 2 dickweed sheriffs...sorry, bro! I think if you were to say some of the things you type in these threads to people...like a lounge or pub, you would probably not make as many ridiculous comments...because people wouldn't want to talk to you...you talk about your Mexican food bowel movements and crapping all the time...sometimes your posts are disgusting...it's not very classy to talk about poo-pooing and farting so much...just sayin'

...maybe try a more imaginative theme when you dislike something...

[Jazzydave]

At least I tried to make amends on that thread and put it behind me. You felt the need to keep it going on. Believe me I could have kept that train going Bro......but out of respect for my man Jon Silberman who I have Mucho respect for I let it go. I suggest you do the same . You do not want me opening the can of worms that is the Deadheads . Remember John Rambo's Famous words to the Sheriff in the first Blood Flick? LET IT GO. http://www.thegearpage.net/board/images/icons/icon12.gifhttp://www.thegearpage.net/board/images/icons/icon14.gif

Absolutely!! Thats exactly what I was doing. But apparently only one opinion is allowed. You guys want to prove that your so open minded........in truth your just the opposite. http://www.thegearpage.net/board/images/icons/icon13.gif My point was that if you are on a guitar related Forum don't be so appalled when you get people that dig guitar orientated music and not electronica psycho babble .

How's that? How does not liking Lady ga Ga = that? :confused:


I'll tell you what......I'll keep my chin up high. I never once, not once attacking anyone personally here or in any other thread. And it wa sthe Sheriff that wanted to arrest John Rambo. His deputy fell out of the Helicopter. Very bad anology. But.........if you would like to pick this back up over at the Dead thread Just let me know. I graciously left but can drag the legacy of Jerry and his Brethern as deep down as you make me.

Thank You.Apparently I'm not allowed to have that same opinion. :dunno

Ahhhh. Thanks for your honesty. http://www.thegearpage.net/board/images/icons/icon14.gif So he said everything you wanted to say , but you felt the need to agree with him attacking me , so you posted it again. Thats all well and good.........but on one hand all of you are preaching freedom of speech, to be free to perform and express yourself . And then all of you condemn me for expressing mine.

The comments were never attacking , and I always gave reasons and explained as to why I felt the way I did. Not to mention this is a GUITAR based Forum. So you would think you would get some people that are interested in GUITAR related music. I think your aware of that going in.

Whatever floats your boat. :bkw

You really seem to have a way of ticking people off...I don't think I've seen a conversation recently that you didn't get someone going.

Sometimes its better just to back up and start over...

[jimfog]

Thank You.Apparently I'm not allowed to have that same opinion. :dunno

ORLY?!?!?!?

Ummmmm...

1. my simple personal view is that if her music was still what was displayed in that first video, I'd be a fan.
2. the stuff she produces today is of no value to me, period.

≠


Too bad its 2009 and she is just a shell of that once beautiful young Lady. :dunno

I just don't see how it compares at all to the Crap she is spewing today and her looks. ....... I would hate to see her end up in a rehab.


Doesn't matter if you take it out of the Toliet bowl and serve it with Lobster..........Crap is still Crap!!

just got flushed along with todays Lunch special

However I still think Lady Gag sux like a Crack whore with the Navy in Town.

Shitty material is shitty material.

Lets just say you could bury that video in the garden and you would probably have a Fine crop grow as a result..........:rolleyes:

I've eaten at the all you can eat Mexican buffet and flushed better things down the bowl then that Video..............http://www.thegearpage.net/board/images/icons/icon13.gif

:huh

So let's review.

Mojocaster = a simple, reasonably stated "I don't dig it". Cool.

Old School = A barrage of vile character assassination and ugly spewage, with an unfortunate scatological fetish.

etuPF1yJRzg

[gainiac]

you felt the need to agree with him attacking me , so you posted it again.

Oops! I stand corrected! A passive aggressive presumptuous ignorant fool. One man's observation of the truth hurts.

Bwahahahahahaaaa!

Here's my favorite smiley: :banana

[rob2001]

Why do guitarists feel the need to argue about a pop star??

[gainiac]

You may as well give up with OldSchool,
Don't waste your keystrokes on OldSchool.

Done! Ignore list engaged!

[gainiac]

Why do guitarists feel the need to argue about a pop star??

Musician first guitarist second. Yes/no?

[Jazzydave]

Musician first guitarist second. Yes/no?

Yes. :beer

[John Alexander]

...OldSchool, you're cool...I appreciate what you do for a living BIGTIME...a crapload, you might say...:p...but, please, less crappy posts...

[rob2001]

Musician first guitarist second. Yes/no?


Agree, but what is there to argue about?

[gainiac]

Agree, but what is there to argue about?

That part of being a musician is respect for others hard work in this very unforgiving business whether you dig their form of self expression or not.

That is the point.

[rob2001]

That part of being a musician is respect for others hard work in this very unforgiving business whether you dig their form of self expression or not.

That is the point.

Again, I totally agree. I just don't see that as debatable. She's doin it, slaggers here are not.

I guess the "debate" is more about people not having that respect for a fellow musician. To me that kind of disrespect clearly shows they have no idea what they are talking about.

[gainiac]

I guess the "debate" is more about people not having that respect for a fellow musician. To me that kind of disrespect clearly shows they have no idea what they are talking about.

Yes...and it's a button of mine.

[OldSchool]

=John Alexander;7165548]...I confused the 2 dickweed sheriffs...sorry, bro!

Actually is was a Sheriff AND a deputy. I'm just saying that if your trying to make a dumb joke ..........you did good!















I think if you were to say some of the things you type in these threads to people...like a lounge or pub, you would probably not make as many ridiculous comments...because people wouldn't want to talk to you...you talk about your Mexican food bowel movements and crapping all the time...sometimes your posts are disgusting...it's not very classy to talk about poo-pooing and farting so much...just sayin'



Sorry it took a bit to answer........Had the chicken wings and a Shrimp Basket for Lunch during the NFL sunday games. I now know what it is like to experience Child birth. :rolleyes:


...maybe try a more imaginative theme when you dislike something



Like mixed up Movie themes and characters? No thanks.......http://www.thegearpage.net/board/images/icons/icon11.gif.http://www.thegearpage.net/board/images/icons/icon10.gif

[OldSchool]

Oops! I stand corrected! A passive aggressive presumptuous ignorant fool. One man's observation of the truth hurts.

Bwahahahahahaaaa!

Here's my favorite smiley: :banana

Can't grasp the concept of Non Personal attacks.......Ignore.

[Scott Peterson]

So, most of you are grown men.... right? :rolleyes: