Need Help with song intro

[Jimmydeez]

So our producer/engineer put together two versions of this song. One version has a small radio effect. One has the original mix version.

I want to know which one you guys like better and why. I am leaning one way but I'm not going to share which way that is just yet.

Let me know what you think:

TATTOO RADIO INTRO A/B TEST (http://soundcloud.com/jimdesanto/sets)

This is my first real album and I would love any feedback you guys can give.

Thanks,
Jim

[Mondoslug]

Well opinions are like ya know.

The lo fi intro thing is cool & artsy but IMO it might take a little too long to get there so maybe I'm going with Version B...plus the acoustic intro is cool...or possibly tighten up Version A where it doesn't take as long to get into the full meal deal....since you asked.

or not....

Good job though & good luck with it.

[Gigbag]

Well opinions are like ya know.

The lo fi intro thing is cool & artsy but IMO it might take a little too long to get there so maybe I'm going with Version B...plus the acoustic intro is cool...or possibly tighten up Version A where it doesn't take as long to get into the full meal deal....since you asked.

or not....

Good job though & good luck with it.

I agree with this opinion.

[moredirt]

I agree, I would come out of the radio thing suddenly as the vocal starts.

[Jimmydeez]

Thanks guys! My thoughts exactly.