Build a Warmoth guitar?

[mbratch]

I was just musing.... has anyone here built their own guitar from components from a place like Warmoth? Is it a cost-effective way to get a good quality guitar (assuming you put it together right, of course )?

I've built several Warmoth guitars and they haev all turned out well. It is a good way to get your feet wet in luthiery and end up with something very useable. I have found Warmoth to be excellent to deal with.

[Clorenzo]

I've built four Warmoth guitars and I'm finishing my second bass. The've all turned out excellent quality for the money. All the woods were very "musical", the finish work they do is top notch (I wouldn't say it's expensive for the quality you get but you could save good cash if you finish yourself), the fit of necks and bodies is perfect (you will have to sand down a bit the heel of a finished neck so it fits though) and the fretwork is very good, I always dress the frets just in case but usually it wouldn't have been necessary. They also have a good selection of hardware at good prices and the choice of body shapes, woods, fret sizes, neck contours, peghead shapes, etc. is huge. All the guitars and basses I've put together would have been impossible to find off the shelf and would have costed a lot more if custom ordered.

The cons are: you obviously can't play the guitar before buying; low resale value, if that bothers you; if you order custom pieces, not from the Showcase, you don't know what they will look like till you get them (in my case they've always turned out way beyond my expectations). Oh, and they don't provide a truss rod wrench with each neck, which they should.

[j_hotch]

I built my frankenstrat out of Warmoth and Stew-Mac parts. I lived in an apartment at the time, so everything had to be pre-finished. It was my first assembly project I am extremely happy with the results! The Dan Erlewine book was of immense help to me in getting the guitar set up just right after assembly.

[guitarmook]

If you want something out of the ordinary, like a les paul body with a telecaster neck, and jazzmaster pickups, it's definately cost-effective to go with warmoth, et.al.

If you want a 'good strat' or a 'good tele', you can probably get the same quality for less $$$ if you look for your basic used Fender.

I've had a couple warmoth pieces, and may do more... but IMHO, the way they compete is with the options and combinations you can't just go purchase... they can't really compete w/ Fender on a straight-up strat or tele...

[Gary Ladd]

I got GAS for making my own custom guitars last year & started-out with Warmoth, but ended-up with USACG in the end...

HUGE selection of options at Warmoth, but the quality is not there - 2 out of 3 Warmoth orders had over-sized pockets on the bodies (which my luthier clear-coated to size), the one body I ordered from scratch with AAAAA top had a major flaw, and the fretwork on 2 out of 3 was shoddy to say the least...

Since then I've ordered 2 guitars from Tommy @ USA Custom Guitar and they were perfect in every respect, and the tonewood was FAR superior to anything I've seen from Warmoth...

Good luck

[johnmfer]

Like Gary Ladd said, the selection of options is huge at Warmoth (and just keeps getting bigger), and that's why I went with them versus other parts manufacturers when I built mine. I had some ideas about how to modernize a jazzmaster, the same way teles and strats had evolved over time to include more modern features. Warmoth offered most of what I was looking for at the time including all the hardware and everything. It just seemed easier overall, and hardware compatibility (proper holes drilled) seemed assured by ordering everything from one company.

I had some finish issues with the neck within the first year. The finish was peeling off on the bass side of the neck around the 12th fret markers. They were very helpful and refinished the whole neck for me with a warranty claim, leaving me very impressed with the customer service. However, I am starting to have the same issue again, only on the treble side of the neck that faces down, and it's only about the size of the head of a pin. The guitar is about three years old now, so being out of warranty I can't send it back for another refin. Luckily I don't see the flaw unless I'm looking for it, and it hasn't gotten worse since I first noticed it several months ago. While the rest of the guitar is beautiful, this kind of quality is somewhat disturbing. It was my main gigging guitar for about two years and while it has a few bumps and bruises, the finish should not be flaking off anywhere.

I'm seriously GAS-ing for another project and have been hearing great things about USA Custom Guitars from various sources around the 'net.

[Mark C]

I've ordered from both Warmoth and USACG and have to say that USACG's customer service is second to none. So far I've only received some uncut swampash from USACG, and that was a killer body blank. I have two necks and a strat body on the way, so I hope they live up to their reputation. I'll probably never order from Warmoth again, I wasn't happy with their service and quality.

[flicker180]

loved Warmoth.

did all my transactions over the phone with them; they were patient, really knowledgable, and haven't had any problem.
tight fitment, one of the best necks ever (flat radius birdseye onepiece neck), and just generally awesome. my AAA quilted maple laminate body was really quilt heavy (which i prefer) and fantastic.

ordered electronics from Stew Mac. meh. they're ok.

dave

[Mike Dresch]

Warmoth has been great for me. I've put together about 6 or 7 guitars and currently have a body and neck on order from them. I called them up at the end of their work day recently to check on the progress of my parts. The rep went out to the floor and checked on each of my items and gave me a detailed run down on where they were at. Nothing but good things to say from me.

[Gary Ladd]

I wonder if some people really know what a tight neck pocket feels like, cause my luthier not only has shown me MANY other botched Warmoth jobs he's had in his shop for repair (he's a VERY popular 2nd gen luthier, in fact he builds Tommy's guitars for him), but he tells me over the years Warmoth's quality has gone to total crap & he very seldom sees decent neck pockets from them over the last couple of years...

At first I thought it was me, but after seeing some of the othercrap floating around out there I now know better

Even my MIA 1990 HM strat had a better fit than the 3 Warmoth's I ordered...in fact it was so tight I had to tap the neck out with the palm of my hand, so I could send it to a friend for SS frets

EDIT: In case anyone didn't know, Mr. Warmoth himself was so pissed-off at one batch of bodies that his employees over-sanded the pockets on, he used them as frisbees in a fit of rage...LOL

[PAF]

best tele I've ever played is my USACG

[Twangmaster]

Originally posted by Gary Ladd


EDIT: In case anyone didn't know, Mr. Warmoth himself was so pissed-off at one batch of bodies that his employees over-sanded the pockets on, he used them as frisbees in a fit of rage...LOL

Thats' pretty hard on employees, isn't it... I mean slinging a hardworker at a wall...


Warmoth has good stuff, no doubt. No resale, usually, but then again, if you build what you really want, what reason do you have to sell it?

[fullerplast]

Originally posted by Gary Ladd
I wonder if some people really know what a tight neck pocket feels like, cause my luthier not only has shown me MANY other botched Warmoth jobs he's had in his shop for repair (he's a VERY popular 2nd gen luthier, in fact he builds Tommy's guitars for him), but he tells me over the years Warmoth's quality has gone to total crap & he very seldom sees decent neck pockets from them over the last couple of years...

At first I thought it was me, but after seeing some of the othercrap floating around out there I now know better

Even my MIA 1990 HM strat had a better fit than the 3 Warmoth's I ordered...in fact it was so tight I had to tap the neck out with the palm of my hand, so I could send it to a friend for SS frets

EDIT: In case anyone didn't know, Mr. Warmoth himself was so pissed-off at one batch of bodies that his employees over-sanded the pockets on, he used them as frisbees in a fit of rage...LOL

Still haven't gotten over that AAAAA top, have you Gary? Your constant Warmoth bashing is getting a little old.

The neck pockets are cut with a CNC machine, as I'm sure you know. They are as tight a tolerance as you can get with wood. The pockets are as tight as they have ever been. Do you really think they've gone in and changed the program to mismatch the pockets and the necks? As for "over-sanding the neck pocket", you've lost all credibility.

[Gary Ladd]

Originally posted by fullerplast
Still haven't gotten over that AAAAA top, have you Gary? Your constant Warmoth bashing is getting a little old.

The neck pockets are cut with a CNC machine, as I'm sure you know. They are as tight a tolerance as you can get with wood. The pockets are as tight as they have ever been. Do you really think they've gone in and changed the program to mismatch the pockets and the necks? As for "over-sanding the neck pocket", you've lost all credibility.

I used to think that perhaps you were a Warmoth employee, but since you're not aware that the incident I spoke of is 100% true, I guess not