The analogy between bands and teams only goes so far.
I think what matters with bands is having a critical mass of definitive members. In some bands, that's all of them. In some bands, it may be as few as one.
Some bands can't be the band without one or more particular original members...
I enjoy listening to some of them. The Giles Martin Beatles remixes and Steven Wilson's Yes remixes are worthwhile, IMO. I don't view them as substitutes for the originals. Their goal, it seems to me, is to shine light on different aspects of the recording, not to make it sound like its from a...
No. Not necessary, or even particularly desirable.
I can see wanting a version of And Justice for All with audible bass in addition to, but not in place of, the original.
But the first 3 stand up perfectly well with no alterations.
If Kill 'Em All were made less gritty and punky, it would...
That interview . . . You can find the whole thing on YouTube. Not going to post it.
I think this is one of those cases of a person, often a famous or powerful person, who is very heavily insulated from ever having to genuinely consider another person's thoughts.
Not my idea of someone I'd...
I'm in favor of it.
If a band has a good set of originals, throwing in a couple of covers 1) is fun for the band and the audience and 2) honors the community of musicians.
If, on a gig in 2022, the Stones can play a Beatles song, literally no one should think they're so good or so important...
Chickenfoot's Highway Star is, indeed, really good. They all clearly love the song, and they're all putting their hearts into it.
I'm a huge Satriani fan, but I've never listened to the Chickenfoot albums more than once or twice. Maybe I need to revisit them, but I don't remember anything that...
Gossard and Ament were already pretty well-known. Mother Love Bone was on the verge, before Wood's untimely death, people following SubPop likely knew Green River.
Chris Cornell was certainly well-known. I remember talk about Soundgarden in the late 80s-early early 90s.
Vedder and McCready...