I have never used the analogman, but i own the keeley.
If you are happy with the tone you have right now and just want it a little bit fatter the...
Its got to be the ts 808 straight up blues distortion it really sounds great with a boost from my ocd though
Boss Chromatic tuner
Dunlop Wah 535q
Ibanez tube screamer 808
Digitech that gives me a great tone I dont know how...
I play with my pick and my nail files down. Does it take tone away?