Built in dirt or seperate pedal?

[oneidabow1]

Whats your preference? And what do you use?

 

[LPMojoGL]

After having many different amps and pedals, I prefer built in.
The best distortion pedals I've tried, Carl Martin Plexitone and Wampler Pinnacle, are really close, but don't have the same feel as built in distortion.
I wouldn't hesitate to recommend either pedal for someone wanting rocking tones through clean-ish amp, though. They are awesome.

 

[semi-hollowbody]

both
I have a few master control/dual channel amps (classic 30, HRDX, Vox ad30vt) and I like the amps crunch AND dirt pedals

 

[ROKY]

I like amp dirt and pedal dirt .

 

[tele_jas]

I like amp dirt and pedal dirt .

Me too....But let me elaborate a bit.

For overdrive and heavy overdrive, I like pedals better...... For moderate and heavy distortion, I like the amp to give it to me.. but that depends on the amp too. For as little as I use distortion now-a-days, I'm good using/stacking pedals to get me there. Now 5 years ago I would have been the exact opposite, but I played distortion 85% of the time (80s cover band), now I'm clean or slightly overdriven 85% of the time.

To be honest, I can cover most of what I play with any clean amp and a Tubescreamer.

 

[Dave_C]

Whats your preference? And what do you use?

BOTH! Neither one is better than the other. They're just different...and can be used separately or together. They're both great tools to have in the box.

 

[UncleLarry]

I've flipped back and forth through the years and now I actually use both. Love my Mesa's gain channel for heavy stuff and use a Timmy into the clean channel for low gain crunch. Tube amp higher gain tones clean up much better than most distortion pedals do when you roll off the guitar volume. Lots of tone colors can be had that way.

 

[SPROING!]

Champ and a volume knob for me, please.

 

[MickyZ]

For me, playing classic rock: amp OD and an Alex's attenuator = sonic nirvana.

 

[tonegangster]

Amp

 

[gtrs]

Dirt needs to come from the amp for me.
Then I push the front end with clean boosts mostly.
KoT, Sunlion, RC Boost and I'd like to add a Tim, Kalamazoo and Sex Drive.

 

[Stu Cats]

Both 2gder r gud 4 teh brootalzz!!11!1!!Omg!!Lulz

 

[jlagrassa]

I prefer pedals into a clean amp, you can change your tones or the voicing a lot easier with the right pedals.

 

[rockonomics]

Two ways to look at it. If you only need one OD sound and your amp has it, you're set. But what happens if/when you want something different? If you only have your amp's OD you're a bit limited. Pedals are fairly cheap by comparison. Get a good clean amp and add some pedals. When you get tired of one pedal, get another.

 

[Figaro]

If you have a good, versatile amp (like a RedPlate!) a pedal is not needed.

 

[CharAznable]

I use both for reasons of variety and practicality.

But when I kick in amp gain, there's no contest. It's just better.

 

[schrom81]

I like pedals because I grow tired of distorted tones after a while. It is a lot cheaper to buy a new dirt pedal then to replace a amp.

 

[timmy2tone]

I haven't played through every available combination of guitars and amps, but based on what I've owned in the past, I just get a better tone with pedals (or cascading pedals) into a clean tube amp! That's just me! LOL

 

[Prerequisite]

Low to med gain ODs into high-headroom amps are the way to go.

 

[Frank Speak]

BOTH! Neither one is better than the other. They're just different...and can be used separately or together. They're both great tools to have in the box.

^
This