Celestion Blues really are great speakers!

Nah, they suck.

Just kidding. Love mine; I have a greenback and a blue together in a 90's AC30/6TB reissue. What a sound.

 

The Red Fangs just sound dull next to Blues, flat and bland.

Now Scumbacks that is entirely different, better bass, nice bright highs without any harshness, like vintage Vox silvers from the middle to late 60s. I have both 60s Silvers and reissue Blues and had a Scumnico here for a show down. Ordered four more Scumnicos for the ultimate 4x12 like from the JTM45/100 days can't wait.

 

I agreee! And for higher power needs, the golds are sweet too!

 

About $40 cheaper than a Blue.:BOUNCE

 

they are decent sounding speakers, the low power handling and tone do not work for me tho.

 

for chimey grind in a low powered amp they sound great!

http://media.putfile.com/plus-Fulldrive

.

 

The pope really is catholic!

The bear really does **** in the woods!

 

What model scumbacks are you referring to exactly? I didn't see them here on my first look.. http://www.southbayampworks.com/speakers.html

 

Another Blue/Gold fan! Anyone tried a Blue with a Matchless Spitfire?

 

New web site http://www.scumbackspeakers.com/

 

FWIW, I just loaded my 2x12 oversize closed-back cabinet with a Red Fang and a Stonehenge. The two together are perfect for what I want, but keep in mind that my cabinet is pretty big (24x31x14), so there's a LOT of air in there -- the cab has a heavy bass end. I wouldn't hesitate to swap in a Blue for the RF, but the Blue comes in at $100 more and the 15W power capacity in a 2x12 (limiting my amp to 30W, and with a quad of JJ6V6S's, I think I'll be exceeding that from time to time) is not up to what I need.

I think the new Eminence line is pretty darned good, even though at heart I'm still a Weber fan; my favorite speaker in a 1x12 open back being his G12H30-55. One of these days I'm going to have to get one of his Alnicos. I'd go for his Alnico Blue Dog, but I find that speaker to be a bit honky in the midrange; good for an open-back and a vox-type circuit, but not so good for a closed-back with my circuit. Were I you, I wouldn't hesitate to get a RF, because you can always flip it here on TGP pretty quickly (probably to me ), but the Blue is a great speaker (for most any style of music, believe it or not) if you can deal with the power handling issue.

rooster.

 

sorry, have not had a chance to compare them, but for some reason I don't gravitate to eminence sprks, but maybe the newer ones are better, I tried alot of them when helping voice my brothers amps (edwardamp.com), and they didn't sing to our liking...perhaps better now.

back on topic: but the blues are terrific.>!!>.they need time to break in, but when they do, terrific. But I have to admit, they are costly for that extra 5-10% of joyous tone !


hey Griz, the mismatch in efficiency doesn't mess with the tone (blue/greenback combo) ?? ...greens are not as loud, just curious if that screws with phase and spkr load ??????

 

p.s. although not widely advertised, you can most definately push the blues past the 15watt range, apparently they can handle more, I'm pushing a pair with a 100w. superlead and traynor ygl mark III

but, I'm being carfull, that would be an expensive recone !


I know some folks don't recommend going close to the spkr recomend, but I have pushed my pair into 50wattish territory and they can take it....the break in is great too . just be careful.

 

Anyone compare the Celestion Gold or Scumnico with a Jensen Jet alnico?

 

Thanks, no wonder I didn't see it. I think I may have to get a pair of those scumicos

 

Anybody else A/B a blue with a red fang? Just curious & have recently ordered a blue to try this myself...

 

You'd have to get a tech to comment, to really get your answer. I was going to change both to Blues, but I liked what I heard. And since the impedance load per speaker is nominally the same as before, I figured it was a reasonably safe move. So far no problems.

There are audible differences, of course, in tone and volume between the two types of speakers. And it seems to me that occasionally certain notes sound louder out of one than the other.

Odd-pairing speakers, I'm guessing, usually involves differences in efficiency. I'm not sure whether Matchless, 65Amps and others who deliberately combine dissimilar speakers exactly match the efficiency values in a pair.

Good question.