Cover Band Flops

shredtrash

Silver Supporting Member
Supporting Member
Messages
9,728
I've been playing for a long time so I've experienced the flop many times. Someone used the word "sobering" in another post and that's the perfect word for it. It happens less with acoustic shows because of the dance-floor factor in bands but it does happen. Tried playing "Run To You" by Bryan Adams the other evening at a solo gig and it didn't get much of a response. No worries, I have about 250 other songs I can play.
 
Last edited:

I Am Misery

Member
Messages
3,220
i don't know why you guys think these late-era songs (Crue, Maiden, Scorpions) are worth playing in the first place, not surprised that nobody liked them. only the most desperate fans listen to any of that stuff. the Maiden tune was pretty bad.

a little surprised about 'Bitch' myself (one of my favorite RS songs), but i wouldn't imagine it's one that most people know. to the casual listener it might sound pretty generic, especially depending on the band.

Surprised by "I didn't mean to turn you on"
surprised with all three of them myself. good tunes. ...but again, depends on the band. maybe i'm not so surprised. :p
 

data_null

Member
Messages
509
Joined a friend's "alt-rock" band a few years ago just to help out since they needed another guitarist. I wouldn't have called it alt-rock, more like some obscure modern rock with some Foo Fighters, Nirvana, Green Day, Oasis, Kings of Leon, Sublime, Weezer, etc.. thrown in. Played about 12-15 shows with them and almost every song at every show was a flop. No one in this area was even remotely interested in any of that music. It got to be comical after awhile.
 

BigBadOrange

Member
Messages
815
i don't know why you guys think these late-era songs (Crue, Maiden, Scorpions) are worth playing in the first place, not surprised that nobody liked them. only the most desperate fans listen to any of that stuff. the Maiden tune was pretty bad.

:p
In my own defense I hated that maiden tune and did not want to play it. But it WAS a "hit" for maiden and the other band members insisted on it. And, if I remember corrretly, we were TRYING to find something less than 20 years old, lol.
 

jazzfromhell

Member
Messages
4,301
Wheels (Foo F), Dani California, F**k You (Cee Lo Green), Dude Looks Like A Lady, Drive By (Train), Kids in America, Raise Your Glass and Grenade (Bruno M) all bombed when we tried 'em in the set. Completely cleared the dance floor.
 
Messages
1,072
Rush tribute. "Hey guys - nobody ever plays Jacob's Ladder, we should learn it." So we did.

First time we played it, the bar emptied.

So we figured it was because we were playing for a general audience and that's a real deep cut, and we tried it again at a benefit show before an actual Rush concert, for a group of die hard Rush fans.

Bar emptied again.

We now fully understand why nobody ever plays Jacob's Ladder...
 

Crimson Queen

Member
Messages
3,873
I do Astronomy Domine with various bands and by myself. Sometimes audiences are knocked out and super impressed (and talk to me about it) and sometimes they look puzzled, like it's the weirdest thing they ever heard. It can go either way with that one, but the delivery does not change.
 
Last edited:

stratotastic

Member
Messages
7,243
Rush tribute. "Hey guys - nobody ever plays Jacob's Ladder, we should learn it." So we did.

First time we played it, the bar emptied.

So we figured it was because we were playing for a general audience and that's a real deep cut, and we tried it again at a benefit show before an actual Rush concert, for a group of die hard Rush fans.

Bar emptied again.

We now fully understand why nobody ever plays Jacob's Ladder...
:rotflmao Yeah, when songs are never played, there's usually a reason.

Seems almost like a rite of passage for every new cover band with inexperienced players, they go in thinking everyone else is stupid and lame for playing the same old stuff, and they were going to be the ones to break the mold and play whatever they wanted, but with so much *passion* and such awesome rearrangements that the crowd would be blown away. Slowly but surely they start replacing all that crap with stuff from The List (if the band lasts that long).

Also reminds me of the bizarre circumstance when someone in the band suggests adding some mega no-brainer hit to the set, and someone else chimes in with, "everybody plays that, let's play [some obscure song by the same band] instead." :facepalm
 
Messages
1,072
:rotflmao Yeah, when songs are never played, there's usually a reason.

Seems almost like a rite of passage for every new cover band with inexperienced players, they go in thinking everyone else is stupid and lame for playing the same old stuff, and they were going to be the ones to break the mold and play whatever they wanted, but with so much *passion* and such awesome rearrangements that the crowd would be blown away. Slowly but surely they start replacing all that crap with stuff from The List (if the band lasts that long).

Also reminds me of the bizarre circumstance when someone in the band suggests adding some mega no-brainer hit to the set, and someone else chimes in with, "everybody plays that, let's play [some obscure song by the same band] instead." :facepalm
We figured in a room full of Rush freaks, it would go over. But it flopped.

So we called an audible: "Working Man"
 

JPH118

Member
Messages
2,724
I feel like every gig has at least one tune that we’re really nailing and I’m feeling super proud of, usually on the uppity-muso side of the list like a jazz-blues or whatever, and nothing but crickets after... then, we’ll butcher something we’ve done a hundred times like “Pride & Joy” and the place goes bonkers. People, eh?
 

donnievaz

Member
Messages
3,554
SONG FLOP : I was in a band that really worked out Broken Arrow. It was very polished, we nailed it....crickets, followed with Hang On Sloopy and the place went nuts. It was internally infuriating.

BAND FLOP: Was in a short term band with some guys. It was really just a project to play a single gig followed by a wedding. 4 practices in and people I didn’t know showed at my house to replace people already jamming with us.. no band discussion, drummer just behind the scenes made some decisions. Secretly he’s calling me saying we need to replace the lead guitar, he’s calling the lead guitar saying the bass has got to go and one of the guys who came to my house was to replace me....

As nuts as that is... we still practiced and decided to do the two gigs. A few weeks later, the night before the first gig, the drummer got furious with us and told us we weren’t taking this serious and that we needed to quit our jobs. He starts telling us he has connections and that we’re only going to make it if we quit our jobs.

We played the first gig and non of us ever spoke to each other again.
WOW! Crazytown...
 

DrumBob

Gold Supporting Member
Messages
16,943
My old band actually played "Tomorrow Never Knows" live (we recorded it too). I have a Danelectro Back Talk pedal, so I just played a droning backwards C chord, and we were able to do a pretty convincing version. You never saw a place clear out faster. We played it live twice, and twice it bombed. Another one bites the dust.
 

jblake

Member
Messages
2,092
When I was in a jammy cover band we always had this plan that if a song really killed, we would segue into another tune by the same artist. It worked really well almost every time. A notable exception was “Where Is My Mind?” into “Gigantic.” The crowd went from loving us to openly mocking us is less than 30 seconds.
 




Top