Dream Theater- Portnoy or Mangini

Discussion in 'The Sound Hound Lounge' started by mikeratan00, Jul 10, 2019.

Portnoy or Mangini

  1. Portnoy

    61 vote(s)
    88.4%
  2. Mangini

    8 vote(s)
    11.6%
  1. mikeratan00

    mikeratan00 Member

    Messages:
    4,110
    Joined:
    Jul 22, 2008
    Location:
    Mai Pen Rai
  2. mabinogeon

    mabinogeon A really hoopy frood. Silver Supporting Member

    Messages:
    1,037
    Joined:
    Jun 13, 2018
    Location:
    Upper Michigan
    That's a tough one.

    Portnoy was more than half the band back in the day. He was the voice and personality of the band.

    But Mangini is an awesome drummer and seems like a genuinely nice guy. Don't want to hate on him - it wasn't his fault Portnoy left.
     
  3. KHAN

    KHAN Member

    Messages:
    3,172
    Joined:
    May 15, 2006
    Location:
    Ceti Alpha 5
    Not going to vote.

    Mangini is a technical freak. Not that Portnoy was left wanting.

    I tend to like the earlier stuff from all of my favorite bands. Not going to hold that against Mangini.
     
  4. Imem

    Imem Member

    Messages:
    115
    Joined:
    May 22, 2013
    Went with Portnoy for Dream Theater, I think Mangini is a great drummer but haven't really cared much for his work in Dream Theater. Thought he was great on Extreme's Waiting for the Punchline and frankly feel he is a bit wasted in DT. Obviously a great gig for him but feel like he plays too technical and with less groove and feel than he is capable of.
     
    mikeratan00 likes this.
  5. CharAznable

    CharAznable Member

    Messages:
    15,406
    Joined:
    Aug 26, 2008
    Location:
    Leesburg, VA
    I love Mangini but I wanted Marco Minneman to win out.

    Would have been the bold, risky choice.
     
  6. Beto

    Beto Supporting Member

    Messages:
    2,872
    Joined:
    May 17, 2012
    I appreciate DT intensely along a few years and then take a loooong break.

    Currently I'm in one of those breaks, which started around MP's departure. Because of that, I can't comment about DT's music with MM.

    I love a lot of songs and albums that wouldn't be the same - or even have come to exist - without MP.

    OTOH, his increasing trend towards cookie-monster-vocals type of music was going too far in the last albums with him (I assume he was the one - or at least the main person - pushing this tendency based on him coming to sing more and more in each new album). But I have to remark - in spite of loving his playing - that Petrucci's inclination to follow this path also contributed to the current break.
     
  7. mikebat

    mikebat Member

    Messages:
    9,210
    Joined:
    Jan 8, 2014
    Location:
    It's cold outside.
    Mangini is a hell of musician, simply incredibly. But they had magic when Portnoy was in the band.

    I liked Minneman, but....he just did not fit. Same with Lang, that guy has a crushing groove, but they don't need that, they need a super computer of drums, and they picked the right guy.
     
    willyboy likes this.
  8. Blix

    Blix Supporting Member

    Messages:
    21,589
    Joined:
    Mar 11, 2010
    Location:
    Stabekk, Norway
    I don't like MM much. He's crazy good, but he just sounds like a freaking robot.
    There soooo much more heart and passion in Portnoy's drumming to my ears.
     
  9. Doomrider78

    Doomrider78 Member

    Messages:
    557
    Joined:
    Mar 20, 2019
    I disagree: MMin fitted very well, but I suspect they'd already made up their mind to go with Mangini by then.

    For me: Portnoy, all the way. Having said that, the new album is great.
     
    mabinogeon and teleman1 like this.
  10. KHAN

    KHAN Member

    Messages:
    3,172
    Joined:
    May 15, 2006
    Location:
    Ceti Alpha 5
    Minnerman plays with too much joy to be in Dream Theater. They take themselves too seriously. Serious faces for serious music. lol
     
  11. mikebat

    mikebat Member

    Messages:
    9,210
    Joined:
    Jan 8, 2014
    Location:
    It's cold outside.
    Exactly. And...."stop that grooving, we need precision!"
     
  12. CharAznable

    CharAznable Member

    Messages:
    15,406
    Joined:
    Aug 26, 2008
    Location:
    Leesburg, VA
    Yeah, Marco Minneman can't play precise

     
    Bob Maximus, sedawkgrep and teleman1 like this.
  13. PaisleyWookie

    PaisleyWookie Member

    Messages:
    5,472
    Joined:
    Feb 27, 2015
    Location:
    Travel A LOT!
    I liked DT a lot. It's a shame they broke up after Scenes From a Memory. :D
     
  14. 2HBStrat

    2HBStrat Member

    Messages:
    39,953
    Joined:
    Apr 3, 2009
    Location:
    East of the Rockies...
  15. derekd

    derekd Supporting Member

    Messages:
    35,882
    Joined:
    Sep 10, 2007
    Location:
    In a van down by the river
    How do you not like'em both?

    They are both incredible drummers. No vote here.
     
    cratz2 likes this.
  16. DrSax

    DrSax Member

    Messages:
    6,243
    Joined:
    Nov 16, 2004
    Location:
    between a rock and a hard place
    Dream Theater is everything people accused Rush of being (but weren't in reality).
     
    PaisleyWookie likes this.
  17. teleman1

    teleman1 Supporting Member

    Messages:
    13,851
    Joined:
    Mar 17, 2006
    Location:
    AIRY ZONY
    Marco Minneman is Bill Bruford on steroids. I love both of them.
     
    Dr Bonkers likes this.
  18. DrewH

    DrewH Member

    Messages:
    2,466
    Joined:
    Dec 1, 2012
    Location:
    Palm Coast Florida
    Portnoy is an example of how important a drummer is to both the song and the process of writing it. Dream Theater never takes off without Portnoy. His drumming on Images and Words + Awake was brilliant from both a creative and technical standpoint.

    Mangini is a fine studio type drummer but he has no originality or soul. He's just very technically bland.
     
    inquintessence and mikeratan00 like this.
  19. mikebat

    mikebat Member

    Messages:
    9,210
    Joined:
    Jan 8, 2014
    Location:
    It's cold outside.
    Yeah, you are totally getting my point, which was supposed to be light hearted.
     
    TubeStack likes this.
  20. Nyarlathotep

    Nyarlathotep Member

    Messages:
    67
    Joined:
    Mar 31, 2019

Share This Page

  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice