I am considering a semi hollow to add to the collection (currently have a Gibson SG and Epi Les Paul Tribute Plus) and these 2 look very nice. I have played the Sheraton II in GC and liked it it alot. Very nice feel, good full sound etc. I never played the Lucille but it looks like a very nice guitar and some of the videos I have seen it sounds pretty good as well. In addition I am even considering a Gretsch 5422T which I know is very different. I know I am kind of all over the map here but I am hoping to hear from some people with some experience with any of these.