How much does NO COA hurt value?

It shouldn't hurt THAT much in resale, but it will a little because some people need that piece of paper. I would rather have a killer guitar with no Cert than a turd with one. Good luck!

 

It depends on who is buying.

I could care less, and if I liked the guitar it wouldn't bother me at all.

Others might feel differently though, so resale might be a consideration.

But since it is local you can play before you buy.....

 

If you're buying to to KEEP and PLAY....zero.

If you ever go to sell it, the missing COA could rear its ugly head.

You also "might" be able to contact Fender...and receive a duplicate COA..if even for a fee. They would have to be able to verify everything, but this might be an option.

 

I would contact Fender. I don't know how Fender deals with it, but Gibson sent me the COA for my LP no problem. I got it at GC, but it was missing the COA. I just emailed Gibson with the serial number.

 

although it's not a big deal to me, it does seem to have an impact on price generally. I think depending on the CS guitar (especially if it's MB) i think it could move the price several hundred dollars. that has been my experience in both buying and selling at least (my experience is with Fender CS btw, not sure about Gibson/other brands)

 

Fender will not issue another COA. There is only the one issued with the guitar. A missing COA definately hurts resale big time because it is the proof of authenticity of the guitar in question. Usually it can be 25%-30% deduction from value.
If on the other hand if you are gonna buy it as a player, and the price is what you consider fair, then buy it and play it. But if you have no proof that it is what it is, then it may as well be a parts-o-caster so don't worry about resale just play it and enjoy.
Best Regards!

 

Egg-zactly! My incredibly superb, good-as-any-real-vintage-60s Tele I've seen closet Classic 63 came used (1 yr old) with no COA, but in great condition w/ all case candy etc. I didn't hesitate a second... if the guitar is that/this good, the COA is almost irrelevant because as in this case, there is so little chance I'll let it go in any foreseeable time frame it's not an issue.

cheers,
jon