Recording Acoustic Fingerpick Guitar on a tight budget

Yeah, my first thought (which you edited in) was mic position. It makes a HUGE difference on acoustic...easily as much as the mic you choose.

 

Don't waste your money and time with the acoustic modeling stuff. It won't sound better than your condenser mic.

Try moving your mic nearer to the 12th fret while pointing to the direction of the sound hole. That should cut out some unnecessary bass. There's no reason why you shouldn't be able to get a decent sound out of your setup.

 

Large diaphragm condensers have pretty strong proximity effect, meaning that they greatly enhance bass response when close to the source (think Howard Stern's radio voice)

Around the 12th fret pointed a bit towards the bridge works great. I literally put on the headphones, hit a chord and slowly move the guitar's position until it sounds best.

 

That particular MXL model leaves a lot to be desired.I would use a V67.You can pick one up for less than 100$.Mic Placement sould be aound the 12th fret.

 

I have an MXL 603 SDC that sounds great, for the price. The KEL HM1 is pretty nice too. Both are under 150. The KEL sounds great on guitar cabs too. Check the tunes on my Myspace to hear what I did with them. I use a Tasco USB interface -> Macbook w/Garageband.

But I'll second the suggestion of playing around with placement before spending more on something else. Any condenser should give decent results if placed right. A tiny shift in mic position can have a big effect. Once you learn how to get decent placement, you'll then get the most out of a better/more appropriate mic.

One problem though, once I got better at micing my acoustic I realized that it really didn't sound all that great and I had to get a better sounding one!

 

I usually try to use two mics, one at 12th and pointing backwards and one at the bridge facing forwards. Even if they are both 57s, I get great results(to me). I DO however record both mics to separate tracks so that I can mix them in as I want. Stereo isn't as important as pan so you can juggle them how you want. Just my opinion, of course. By the way, I DO use 57's for guitar a lot.

 

I'd guess you put the mic right in front of the soundhole, right? Don't do that. Nothing but boom there. Don't let your eyes decide where the sound comes from!

There's nothing wrong with your gear... heck, I recently recorded some guitar with the MXL 991 (sibling to the 990, same capsule) and was amazed at how good it sounded. And the Audio Buddy preamp is fine, too. Did you get the two-mic kit from Guitar Center? Use the small one rather than the big one, if you have both. The big one is good, but the small one is actually excellent.

Here's what I'd do to start... place the mic out about a foot away from the 9th fret, aimed back at the neck-body joint. That may not be the best possible position, but I guarantee it'll be GOOD and give you a usable sound. Try recording that and see if you get a pretty good balance. If not, the problems aren't with the mic and placement, but rather elsewhere in the chain.

Assuming your balance is good, you can start experimenting with mic placement. One that works for me sometimes is over the bridge, aimed between the bridge and the end of the guitar. Another is over your right shoulder (assuming you're right handed), as close to your ear as you can comfortably manage, aimed down at the bridge.

Make sure you aren't overdriving your mic preamp or the Tascam's inputs, either. Don't record "hot"... you don't want anything anywhere NEAR clipping! Acoustic guitars have a huge dynamic range and you may not see the clipping on the meters, but you'll hear it on the recording. And record in 24 bit mode, which gives you a lot of downward dynamic range.

You can make great recordings with the gear you've got. It just takes some practice and learning!

 

Almost forgot... if your room sounds pretty decent, a less obvious mic techique is setting the mic a few inches away from the wall, pointing at the wall. This gives you reflections rather than direct sound. In some contexts, it can sound really nice.

 

Another thing to consider.........be very wary of your playing technique. If you want a smooth dynamic to your recording it's really important that you fingerpick that way as well. Pay close attention to your right hand as your performing the part and balance out the dynamics. Get your high strings consistently louder and be careful on the low strings.

 

Maybe in a concert hall as an accent mic, but for intimate fingerpicking I wouldn't bother. All you'll get is room, and it won't be pretty.

I second the idea that you can get decent results from something as low-brow as an SM 57. I was doing some comparisons between an SM 58 and a Beta 58, and was pleasantly surprised at the clarity of sound. I wouldn't normally do this, preferring to use a small diaphragm condensor like an AKG C-451 or Shure SM 81, but many mics can give good results.

It really is about placement. Wear good headphones and move mic/guitar relationship until you find what works.

Also, don't rule out the Fishman Aura pedal. I will often use one in conjunction with mics to help even out the sound. It is particularly effective if your guitar is not up to concert quality! Use some of the direct pedal down the center with 2 mics spread wide on separate tracks and you have a lot of options in the mix.

Bob

 

Perhaps try moving the mic away about 8" from the hole as others have stated. Try positioning the mic around the 14th fret at an angle so the blast from the soundhole does not hit the mic straight on. That's the key really.
I have better luck with smaller bodied guitars than D or Jumbo sized instruments. Sometimes an inexpensive guitar works best. I never record my old Guild D-50 just too boomy. My Tacoma Pm-20 or Cort Parlour get the job done.

 

I tried this and got a very good result. :BEER