I was going to say this -- the Eric Johnson strat specs are kind of perfect. I've got nothing against the guy, but I don't listen to his music.My #1 is an Eric Johnson strat and I don't really listen to his music. Cliffs of Dover is fun every now and then and I'm sure I've heard some of his other songs randomly on spotify cuz his tone is pretty unique, but if it wasn't for that, I could never tell it was an EJ song.
I also love Annie Clark's St. Vincent. It's like an instrument right out of the Jetsons but at the same time looks classic. Her music? Don't care for it all that much. I didn't even know she existed until l saw her guitar. There are maybe one or two songs of hers I like.
Not sure which albums you checked out, but Spoon have been on a downward trend since 2008 or so. Girls Can Tell and Gimme Fiction are fantastic, though.I've subsequently checked out the band. I'll say I'm neutral. I wouldn't change the station if a Spoon song came on the radio...but I likely wouldn't buy a CD of theirs either.