The BUT: The Reverb seller stated it comes with original box and paperwork and I paid a fair rate keeping that in mind. But when the package arrived it came in a mission engineering pedal box and no original paperwork. Turns out his wife put the pedal in the wrong box and shipped it out. Edit: The reason why it's in a mission engineering box is because he also sold one of those and his wife put that pedal in the xotic box (as I understand it). So that's why he can't just send the original box. So, given that he did sell the pedal as described, I asked for either a partial refund or a full return and he pays shipping (since it's his mistake). Now, he balks, won't offer any partial refund since it's just 'paper and a box' says I'm accusing him of lying, even though he literally told me it came with the original box and paperwork in our messages. Anyhoo, am I the a**hole for asking for a partial refund or that he cover shipping since it's the sellers mistake and he misrepresented what I would get?