The Spooky does have great decay and it's a great fuzz. Can go all "white noise into resolution" kinda thing. You said "I play rock, punk, alt, indie and smoke pot," which struck me as being right up the Orpheum's alley. It'll rasp and it'll grind, it's unruly, and it'll get ******* loud. Obviously, you should get them both. I'm sad to report that there's nothing on my radar I want. I must have a fever or something. Well, I guess I do kinda want the EHX Triangle reissue, but it's a Muff (obviously) and I've never grokked the Muff, so I'm only so motivated to pick one up. The Supa Mk 1, Nebula, Gold Bender, and Bad Pixel Buzzaround that I acquired in the first half of 2018 keep hogging all the play time, because they're great. I really probably could strip my whole collection down to those four plus the Echopark F-1, Fuzz Mutant, and I6W9 BC183. Not that I'm going to!