The Torpedo Captor is perfect for my needs on paper. I want to use my amp and speaker to practice with attenuation at home, and avoid to mike it when I play live at Church and still use my attenuated amp as a monitor. If I record I can use an IR on the computer. My only concern is the analog cab sim. Is the cab sim "good enough" for live? I thought of adding an IR based cab sim device but 1) that would add cost and another thing 2) the cheap ones I saw don't have XLR out 3) likely then I would rethink the captor Happy to hear other non crazy expensive alternatives that are ideally just one device: attenuation, XLR out with cab sim.