I have looked all over the internet and compiled this list of Tremelo Pedals that have been praised and put down by many people. I am looking to buy one of these and would like some advice from others who have used these or gone through some of these and have eventually setteld on a favorite. I want something that does the vintage Fender Thing very well but can also be versatile enough to do the more trobbing and choppy square wave stuff too. Good tone is extremely important to me. Of the sound clips I listened to, the Monster effects Swamp Thang was most clearly the winner in the vintage fender only category. I loved it's sound but it is not versatile enough and won't do the throb or chop. Also many people raved about the Demeter tremulator which was designed in part by Ry Cooder of all people but the sound clips are awful and the waveform of the Demeter sounds like it is way to quick to rise in volume even on the slower settings it kind of starts ramping and then whoomp, it shoots up in volume really quick...reminds of a helicopter propellor when it's just getting going. That kind of threw me off because it isn't natural and smooth like a vintage trememlo should be. Not in the sound clips anyway. Many people had great things to say about the Frantone Vibutron but I couldn't find any sound clips of it. The Fulltone Supa-Trem was loved and hated equally. Many people claimed it sounded sterile, like an effect and not part of the amp but an add on. People complain about the noise with the Diaz, the volume boost with the Guyatone Flip, the ticking sound with the Menatone and the darkness of the Demeter. Here they are in no order Austone vibro-stomp BJF Saffron Yellow Tremelo Diaz Texas Tremodillo Demeter Tremulator Toneczar Powerglide Kaden Fluttetone Guyatone Flip VTX Vintage Tube Tremolo Roger mayer voodoo vibe Red Witch Tremelo Dunlop TS-1 tremelo stereo pan Menatone Pleasure Trem 5000 Frantone Vibutron Fulltone Supa-Trem Monster Effects Swamp Thang Auralux King Trem V-Trem by JTPedals Blues Pearl Tejas Trem If you have an opinion that would help me choose one of these please shoot!