Watch Should I replace my Strat pickup covers with relics?

I have a 1983 '62 Reissue Stratocaster which has been reliced just by me playing it for the past 25 years, and I really like the natural "road worn" look. Just recently, I replaced the pickguard with a Fatboy ivory/green relic which looks great, but now I'm wondering if I should also replace the pickup covers to match. When I bought the pickguard, I also bought a set of "Re-Vibe" PU covers which have a kind of "dirty" yellow look. My guitar tech didn't think they looked as if they belonged with the guitar. He thought they would be better suited for a really beat up weathered Strat and he thought the original covers looked just fine. What do you guys think? Here's the guitar with the original 1983 PU covers:



And here is the "Re-Vibe" set:

 

Yeah, the "Re-Vibes" look too dirty compared to the rest of the guitar.

 

I might try it on another Strat someday, but I think this one is done. I was originally going to go "all out" with the "aged" look but I don't think it would match my guitar. The Fatboy "Re-Vibe" pickup covers are a little too yellow and their lighter "Parchment" covers didn't look any better than the ones that are already on my guitar, so maybe it's best to just leave everything as is.

Here's a comparison of the Fatboy "ivory" pickguard and the Fender "Road Worn" pickguard. Looking at them side by side, it's obvious to me that the "Road Worn" pickguard just wouldn't look right on my guitar.

 

I guess it does sort of make it look like one of those Antigua Strats - good thing I didn't settle on that one! It looked a lot better when I saw it on a sunburst model.