What's the current best OD pedal that doesn't color the sound and cleans up well?

Tim/Timmy, I love it for the lack of coloration unless you want it to.

 

+1 on Tim / Timmy or Amp Eleven...

 

I've used Zendrives for many years and would highly reccommend them.

 

Do you want to add drive or are you just looking for a clean boost?

I love the Suhr Koko boost. Hits the front end of my amp with a nice hot clean signal. It doesnt color my sound one bit and cleans up nice with the guitar volume...

 

Solidgold Superdrive. -E

 

I really like the Mad Professor Sky Blue Over Drive and the Lovepedal Eternity

 

^^^The OCD is a good pedal, I have it. BUT, having owned both of these below, they will meet your requirements.

 

Seriously: Solidgold Superdrive. That's what it does: Sounds like your amp cranked up. Totally works with your vol. knob and really responds to your picking. -E

 

I would use a Bearfoot Honey Bee or Sweet Honey Overdrive

 

I forgot about the Sweet Honey Overdrive. That's a good one too.

 

Big fan of the Barber LTD, LTD SR and 1/2 Gainer ( which is two LTD SRs in one box. Great for adding just a bit more OD and volume for leads)

 

Bad Monkey

 

PCFX Fuzzy Lady is your ticket to ride

 

I have the Monte Allums H2O mod to a Boss BD-2 and it is exactly what you described. I have never played a pedal with so little coloration and it has a great gain taper and cleans up perfectly. It is so good I keep it on all the time when I play and use the guitars volume to go crystal clean.

 

I recently picked up a Cause and Effects FET Dream. With my Fender amp, it has settings that are very transparent and it is super dynamic and cleans up well.

 

That's to be expected. There are tons of on-line dealers with great return policies. -E

 

You're going to hear the Tim/Timmy a lot on here, but unlike most of these hyped pedals, the Timmy actually lives up to expectations. Hands down, this is the best light OD pedal I've ever used. It's essential for me. I can't say enough good things about it.

Additionally, fuzz pedals are very interactive with your tone/volume controls, but that's quite a different sound from a true OD.